Applying for U.S. citizenship through naturalization requires more than meeting residency and language requirements.
Applicants must also demonstrate good moral character during the statutory review period, which is usually the five years preceding the submission of a naturalization application (or three years in some marriage-based cases).
Certain criminal convictions can prevent someone from establishing good moral character and may lead to the denial of a naturalization application.
In more serious cases, a criminal conviction can also trigger deportation proceedings.
Understanding which crimes may affect eligibility for U.S. citizenship is critical for anyone with a criminal record who plans to apply for naturalization.
Your most promising avenue for a favorable outcome is to engage an experienced California criminal defense attorney at Esfandi Law Group. To arrange a complimentary consultation, please call (310) 274-6529 or contact us through this link.
The “Good Moral Character” Requirement
To qualify for naturalization, applicants must show that they have been a person of good moral character during the statutory review period.
Immigration authorities consider several factors when evaluating good moral character, including:
-
criminal history
-
honesty in immigration applications
-
compliance with court orders
-
tax obligations
-
past immigration violations
A criminal conviction during the review period may lead immigration officials to conclude that the applicant does not meet this requirement.
Crimes That Can Permanently Bar U.S. Citizenship
Some criminal convictions create permanent bars to naturalization. These offenses prevent a person from ever establishing the good moral character required for U.S. citizenship.
Examples include:
-
murder convictions
-
aggravated felonies committed after November 29, 1990
An aggravated felony conviction may permanently prevent someone from becoming a U.S. citizen and can also lead to deportation.
Crimes That Can Temporarily Affect Citizenship Eligibility
Other crimes may prevent a person from demonstrating good moral character during the statutory review period but may not permanently bar citizenship.
Examples include:
-
multiple criminal convictions
In some cases, applicants may need to wait until enough time has passed before applying for naturalization. It may be possible to reopen an old criminal case and challenge the conviction through post-conviction relief.
Crimes Involving Moral Turpitude
Crimes involving moral turpitude (CIMTs) generally involve dishonesty, fraud, or intent to harm others. Immigration authorities often consider these offenses when evaluating good moral character.
Common examples include:
-
theft
-
fraud
Multiple convictions for crimes involving moral turpitude can affect both citizenship eligibility and immigration status.
Drug Offenses
Drug-related convictions are among the most serious immigration concerns.
Possession, sale, or transportation of controlled substances can:
-
prevent naturalization
-
lead to deportation
-
create permanent inadmissibility in some cases
Even minor drug convictions can cause problems when applying for citizenship.
Multiple Criminal Convictions
Having multiple criminal convictions can also affect eligibility for naturalization.
If a person has been convicted of two or more offenses resulting in combined jail sentences of five years or more, immigration authorities may deny the application based on a lack of good moral character.
Failure to Pay Court-Ordered Obligations
Certain non-criminal issues may also affect citizenship eligibility.
Examples include:
-
failure to pay court fines or restitution
-
unpaid child support obligations
Immigration authorities may interpret these issues as evidence of poor moral character.
Related Crimes That May Affect Citizenship Eligibility
Several criminal offenses frequently impact naturalization applications.
Theft – California Penal Code 484 PC
Theft involves taking someone else's property without permission. Because theft offenses involve dishonesty, immigration authorities may classify them as crimes involving moral turpitude.
Fraud – California Penal Code 532 PC
Fraud offenses involve deception for financial gain. These crimes are commonly considered evidence of poor moral character and may lead to denial of naturalization.
Identity Theft – California Penal Code 530.5 PC
Identity theft involves using another person's personal identifying information without permission. Because the offense involves deception and financial misconduct, it may affect citizenship eligibility.
Drug Possession – Health and Safety Code 11350 HS
Possession of controlled substances can create serious immigration consequences and may prevent applicants from demonstrating good moral character.
Domestic Violence – California Penal Code 273.5 PC
Domestic violence convictions may affect immigration benefits and may also lead immigration authorities to question an applicant's moral character.
Prostitution – California Penal Code 647(b) PC
Prostitution-related offenses may affect immigration status and may also be considered during the naturalization review process.
Post-Conviction Relief for Citizenship Issues
In some cases, individuals with criminal convictions may pursue post-conviction relief to improve their eligibility for naturalization.
Possible legal remedies may include:
-
motions to vacate convictions under Penal Code 1473.7
-
motions to withdraw guilty pleas under Penal Code 1018
-
negotiating immigration-safe plea agreements
These remedies may help remove or reduce the immigration consequences of a criminal conviction.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a criminal record prevent someone from becoming a U.S. citizen?
Yes. Certain criminal convictions may prevent someone from establishing the good moral character required for naturalization.
What crimes permanently prevent citizenship?
Murder and aggravated felony convictions are among the offenses that permanently bar someone from becoming a U.S. citizen.
Can misdemeanors affect citizenship eligibility?
Yes. Even misdemeanor offenses may affect the good moral character requirement depending on the nature of the crime.
Do old criminal convictions affect citizenship?
Possibly. Some crimes permanently affect eligibility, while others only affect the statutory review period.
Can a conviction be challenged before applying for citizenship?
Yes. Some individuals pursue post-conviction relief to vacate or modify convictions that may affect immigration benefits.
Why Legal Advice Is Important Before Applying for Citizenship
Individuals with a criminal history should seek legal advice before applying for U.S. citizenship. Submitting a naturalization application without understanding the immigration consequences of a conviction could lead to denial or even deportation proceedings.
An experienced immigration or criminal defense attorney can:
-
review criminal records for immigration risks
-
determine whether a conviction affects citizenship eligibility
-
advise on post-conviction relief options
-
help applicants prepare for the naturalization process
Proper legal guidance can help individuals avoid serious immigration consequences and protect their path to U.S. citizenship.
Esfandi Law Group is ready to assist you. Feel free to schedule your free consultation by calling us at (310) 274-6529 or simply fill out our contact form here. We're looking forward to helping you!
